[quote="Sim G"
Yep, I’m in agreement with you and CDM5. I reality, it doesn’t make that much difference. And I obviously hold prejudices as I have a number of .22 Marlins that are tube loaded and an 1894 in .32 H&R which is also tube loaded and no gate!
Is your super short Big Boy “brass” or steel framed?[/quote]
It's brass
Kungfugerbil wrote:bradaz11 wrote:I just can't get round the no load gate
It’s horses for courses - if it’s for cowboy action or some form of practical usage where you might need to top up a round under a pressure situation, a loading gate is definitely better.
If it’s for range use where you’re never going to need to reload under time pressure, the tube load is no issue. It’s easier on the thumbs and is at least as quick to load a full tube :)
Luckily there is no right or wrong answer. I played with every available rifle before going for mine and for me it was the best option.
I find it ungainly, you have to bring the rifle back in, hold at an awkward angle, drop more rounds in, replace the tube, then get settled again. completely breaks the rhythm. I much prefer being able to just drop the butt down and push in a few more rounds and continue.