Well the question was could cast boolits solve the problem - this referred to the fact that I started noticing some deterioration of the barrel on my SMLE, so thought of switching to cast boolits to preserve the original barrel rather than re-barrel the rifle - The test was always going to be the Trafalgar meeting; as the loads would have to perform as well as my jacketed ones had in previous years...
...So how did they do?
Having found some loads (20 and 21 gn of VN120 at 1545 and 1614 fps) that shot OK, I then found that they would fit in the magazine - I only had 2 more opportunities to test them before the Trafalgar...
...the new seating depth for the boolit I'm using sort of chose its self, as there was a depth that allowed them to fit the magazine and still keep the gas check in the neck of the case (I cut a cross section out of a prepared case to make sure), and also just covers the first lube strip...
...on the first test they were no good with little consistent grouping - I had stuck to the previous powder loads, and the rifle clearly didn't like the boolit at the increased velocity caused by the deeper seating depth (the previous 'seated out' ones hadn't shot well with more than 21 gns) - For the last test I tried 18 and 19 gns...it wasn't the best day conditions-wise for testing, but they didn't seem too bad; and I decided to go with the 19s for the meeting.
In the precision I managed a 40 (a few points less than usual, and 5 points less than with my Mauser the previous day) with the new loads - But I can't blame the cast boolits for this, as after the last testing I had tried to adjust my fore-sight at home from memory and rough calculation...this was a big mistake, as I ended up with the foresight even further off zero, but in the other direction (

) - This then made things difficult in the snaps, where I was having to aim off into the sand; and with my eyes not being what they used to be was very tricky on an overcast day...it's probably the worst I've ever shot in the snaps...
...but as I say I can't blame it on the boolits - I clearly haven't found just the right load yet, and didn't have the time to zero and practice properly with the final load...
...I also can't blame the barrel, as I took the opportunity at the meeting to get it checked by a couple of different people...they both said the same thing; which was that it wasn't as bad as I though, and that there was no reason why it shouldn't shoot OK...which is great news...
...now knowing that the barrel isn't as bad as I thought, I could give up and go back to jackets, but that also means that there's no reason why it shouldn't shoot cast boolits well...so as I've enjoyed the learning curve so far, I want to see it through, I'm going to go back to the drawing board; do a cast and a better slugging, some more chronoing etc. and persevere with the project...
...surely a full year should be enough time to get it right for the next Trafalgar razz