NRA of America in London

Anything shooting related including law and procedure questions.

Moderator: dromia

Forum rules
Should your post be in Grumpy Old Men? This area is for general shooting related posts only please.
Message
Author
Porcupine

Re: NRA of America in London

#61 Post by Porcupine »

I would love to go but I have plans that evening :bad:

The NRA is the most effective lobbying body in history. It has not only stopped the creep of gun control, it has reversed it with 49 out of 50 states now with legal concealed carry, Washington DC legalizing gun ownership, and federal-level gun control now a non-issue. American politicians have learnt that advocating gun control is political suicide. The NRA works so well for two reasons.

Firstly, it does not hobble itself with the 'sporting' argument. The NRA knows that when you argue against gun control (whose advocates claim it will save lives) on the basis that people need guns for sport, you lose your guns. Non-gun-owning voters do not care about your hobby, if there is even a chance that lives could be saved at the cost of your hobby they will try to save lives every time. Instead the NRA argues that gun rights, not control, saves lives. Self defence, not sport. Nor do they argue simply to maintain the status quo, they aggressively argue to improve and expand gun rights which shifts the debate. It is no longer 'should we ban guns', it is 'do we need to keep banning machineguns?' When your issue is on the fringe, it's easy to lose. Push the fringe way back and even if you lose at the margin, your core interests stay safe.

Secondly, the NRA is highly political. They don't just 'consult' with legislators or appear on the news, they run highly political campaigns to get gun rights supporters registered to vote, to 'approve' pro-gun candidates and get gun rights supporters to vote for them, and to attack and expose anti-gun candidates and ensure gun rights supporters never vote for them. Relatedly, they also push an agenda. Their educational role is not just in firearms safety and proficiency but also in teaching people how guns save lives and the evils of gun control. So while people may join the NRA because they hunt or shoot skeet and actually aren't too sure about concealed carry and think maybe gun registration sounds like a good idea, they are then bombarded with literature and videos and podcasts and all the rest that turn them into ardent gun rights advocates.

The problem in the UK is that BASC and the NRAUK do not use and are terrified of the self-defence argument, they try only to maintain the status quo, on the whole, rather than push for increased rights, they don't involve themselves in electoral politics which means they can be largely ignored, and the vast majority of British shooters don't even really want or believe in gun rights.

<- Lifetime NRA member
Gaz

Re: NRA of America in London

#62 Post by Gaz »

Porcupine wrote:The problem in the UK is that BASC and the NRAUK do not use and are terrified of the self-defence argument, they try only to maintain the status quo, on the whole, rather than push for increased rights, they don't involve themselves in electoral politics which means they can be largely ignored, and the vast majority of British shooters don't even really want or believe in gun rights.
Can you imagine the media coverage if the NRA got political in the same way as the US NRA? It'd be like the aftermath of Dunblane all over again.

The simple truth is that self-defence, rightly or wrongly, isn't an accepted reason for the grant of a firearms certificate. Pushing for that over here would be like lobbying for the immediate release of all sex offenders from prison. What the NRA should be doing, if it goes overtly political, is to lobby for the return of pistols and semi-auto fullbores. Yes, the Firearms Acts are ridiculously restrictive, but let's have one thing at a time.
User avatar
Chuck
Posts: 23986
Joined: Tue Nov 23, 2010 11:23 am
Location: Planet Earth - Mainly
Contact:

Re: NRA of America in London

#63 Post by Chuck »

It'd be like the aftermath of Dunblane all over again.
How they all sat in a corner and said nowt. The best time to raise the self defence point was during the London riots.

I saw a news report a while back about some ex soldier getting the rough end because his semi auto went full auto for some reason. NRA et alwere on tele demanding he be released even the news channel ásked "and where the hell was his congressman"!

At a time when there are calls for defence and "CAMERON fartinatrance" has said we could use force then why not get the right tools for the job....get cameron to actually mean what he says for once.

Dunblane is a red herring, if you keep using it as an excuse nowt will happen. Dunblane KNOWS WHERE THE BLAME LIES. Opps caps. Anyway to use an old argument "one armed teacher would have meant less kids dead"! . At ANY school shooting. Gun free zones are victim rich - every time.

BTW: good post porcupine.
Political Correctness is the language of lies, written by the corrupt , spoken by the inept!
Post Reply

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 8 guests