bullet v ball

Anything muzzle loading in here. Old and new, rifles, shotguns, pistols and even cannons!

Moderator: dromia

Post Reply
Message
Author
User avatar
steve853
Posts: 94
Joined: Thu Jul 25, 2019 5:41 pm
Home club or Range: North Coates Butts
Location: Barton upon Humber, Lincolnshire
Contact:

bullet v ball

#1 Post by steve853 »

Hi all

Thinking about getting a black powder revolver, I used to have a Colt Walker reproduction and I'm thinking of something similar.

My question is this; is it possible to use .44 bullets (I reload .44 Magnum for a lever action) instead of ball? Just thinking ahead, about buying a lead pot and mould, that sort of thing.

Yours Aye

Steve
England Prevails
User avatar
Dark Skies
Posts: 2847
Joined: Tue Apr 22, 2014 11:02 am
Home club or Range: NRA
Contact:

Re: bullet v ball

#2 Post by Dark Skies »

steve853 wrote: Sun Aug 07, 2022 1:33 am Hi all

Thinking about getting a black powder revolver, I used to have a Colt Walker reproduction and I'm thinking of something similar.

My question is this; is it possible to use .44 bullets (I reload .44 Magnum for a lever action) instead of ball? Just thinking ahead, about buying a lead pot and mould, that sort of thing.

Yours Aye

Steve
No. The .44 BP revolvers are in the .454 / .457 diameter range.
.44 Magnums are in the .439 / .430 diameter.

Bullet mould do exist, I've tried them. Results are disappointing compared to ball. Usually the profile of the rammer is at odds with the round and getting them to sit straight in the chamer is a bit of a faff.

That said I've seen custom bullets (moulds) made for BP revolvers specifically have returbned decent results.
"I don't like my job and I don't think I'm gonna go anymore."
User avatar
steve853
Posts: 94
Joined: Thu Jul 25, 2019 5:41 pm
Home club or Range: North Coates Butts
Location: Barton upon Humber, Lincolnshire
Contact:

Re: bullet v ball

#3 Post by steve853 »

Ah now I remember, the .44 magnum is actually a .43, thanks

Reading other posts about storage and licensing requirements for BP substitutes, think I'd better look into it a bit deeper. I used Pyrodex in the past, stored in a lockable wooden box, but there's some confusing information around. And it seems Kranks aren't necessarily the best to ask.

Yours Aye

Steve
England Prevails
User avatar
Dark Skies
Posts: 2847
Joined: Tue Apr 22, 2014 11:02 am
Home club or Range: NRA
Contact:

Re: bullet v ball

#4 Post by Dark Skies »

steve853 wrote: Mon Aug 08, 2022 12:06 am Ah now I remember, the .44 magnum is actually a .43, thanks

Reading other posts about storage and licensing requirements for BP substitutes, think I'd better look into it a bit deeper. I used Pyrodex in the past, stored in a lockable wooden box, but there's some confusing information around. And it seems Kranks aren't necessarily the best to ask.

Yours Aye

Steve
Slight mistype 44 Magnums are in the .429 / .430 diameter.

Currently Pyrodex is available under the same conditions as it was - no need for a wooden box. That said some dealers I've bought from were treating it in the same manner as Hodgon 777 substitute which now requires an explosive licence. As you already have the wooden box I'd get an explosive licence for buying black powder and Hodgon substitute. I'd not bothered until I was pushed into it for purchasing substitutes. And now that I have I only buy black powder. It's a damn sight cheaper and is what the revolvers were designwed for. I've noticed the fouling is easier to clean too.
"I don't like my job and I don't think I'm gonna go anymore."
Triffid
Posts: 407
Joined: Thu Feb 27, 2014 2:36 pm
Home club or Range: Wey Valley
Contact:

Re: bullet v ball

#5 Post by Triffid »

I've experimented with various Lee and Lyman cast bullets in my Ruger Old Army. I never found any improvement in accuracy and have returned to just using round ball. As DS says, loading bullets is much more of a pfaff than ball, for no gain in my experience.
Triffid
User avatar
dromia
Site Admin
Posts: 20144
Joined: Sat Nov 06, 2010 4:57 am
Home club or Range: The Highlands of Scotland. Cycling Proficiency 1964. Felton & District rifle club. Teesdale Pistol and Rifle club.
Location: Sutherland and Co Durham
Contact:

Re: bullet v ball

#6 Post by dromia »

The trick with bullets especially in ML revolvers is getting the bullet seated so that it enters the forcing cone fully centered with the barrel.

This is difficult due to lots of variations, bullets consistency in weigh diameter and alloy softness, then there is diameter in relation to the chamber, then seating concentrically which most loading levers won't do.

So in comparison a round ball over comes all these difficulties but lacks anything meaningful in the BC department where driving them hard over comes this for a while.

Get the bullet seated repeatedly correctly then the longer range, over 75yrds, shots benefit from a better BC bullet.

For most users it isn't worth the effort and the ranges they shoot where the round ball works well.
Image

Come on Bambi get some

Imperial Good Metric Bad
Analogue Good Digital Bad

Fecking stones

Real farmers don't need subsidies

Cow's farts matter!

For fine firearms and requisites visit

http://www.pukkabundhooks.com/
1066
Full-Bore UK Supporter
Posts: 2213
Joined: Wed Aug 31, 2011 7:05 pm
Contact:

Re: bullet v ball

#7 Post by 1066 »

I've also tried various shape/size/weight of various bullets in my .44 Italian 1858 Rem. Best accuracy was obtained with an H&N lead ball.
I've also tried lead balls in my Zylab Patriot .32 five shot M/L target pistol. with good results.
This is 5 shots with ball at 20 yards with the .32 pistol (One hand, open sights, unsupported)

Image
TARGETMASTER
an altogether better trickler
www.targetmasteruk.com
User avatar
AL8
Posts: 681
Joined: Fri Sep 02, 2011 8:27 am
Location: Essex
Contact:

Re: bullet v ball

#8 Post by AL8 »

nice shooting
1066
Full-Bore UK Supporter
Posts: 2213
Joined: Wed Aug 31, 2011 7:05 pm
Contact:

Re: bullet v ball

#9 Post by 1066 »

AL8 wrote: Tue Aug 09, 2022 2:18 pmnice shooting
Thanks - unfortunately doesn't happen very often now. :)
TARGETMASTER
an altogether better trickler
www.targetmasteruk.com
Post Reply

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest