Wet rotary tumbler

This section is for reloading and ammunition only, all loads found in here are used strictly at your own risk, if in doubt ask again.
All handloading data posted on Full-Bore UK from 23/2/2021 must reference the published pressure tested data it was sourced from, posts without such verification will be removed.
Any existing data without such a reference should treated as suspect and not used.

Moderator: dromia

Forum rules
All handloading data posted on Full-Bore UK from 23/2/2021 must reference the published pressure tested data it was sourced from, posts without such verification will be removed.
Any existing data without such a reference should be treated as suspect and not used.

Use reloading information posted here at your own risk. This forum (http://www.full-bore.co.uk) is not responsible for any property damage or personal injury as a consequence of using reloading data posted here, the information is individual members findings and observations only. Always verify the load data and be absolutely sure your firearm can handle the load, especially older ones. If in doubt start low and work your way up.
Message
Author
Keithkilvo1
Posts: 261
Joined: Thu Sep 21, 2017 11:36 am
Home club or Range: ARPC
Contact:

Wet rotary tumbler

#1 Post by Keithkilvo1 »

Thinking of buying one of these and wondered what the views/experiences of the forum members are of these machines.
I’m not interested in manufacturing one but people’s views on the ones already available ie Thumbler, Lyman cyclone, Frankford Arsenals one
Cheers
simong
Posts: 208
Joined: Tue Apr 05, 2011 3:49 pm
Home club or Range: Saxon
Contact:

Re: Wet rotary tumbler

#2 Post by simong »

Evening,

I've got a thumbler ( from JD reloading) and over the last 3/4 years it's done its job exceedingly well.
Produces shinny brass with minimal effort, at a reasonable price ( in my humble opinion, getting brassed off with TLA's )

Best
The greek
Suffolk champion...50 mtr precision flinching champion


Howa 308 GRS stock
Uberti 1873 45 LC
Ruger Precision 6.5
rox
Posts: 1895
Joined: Fri Dec 10, 2010 1:33 pm
Contact:

Re: Wet rotary tumbler

#3 Post by rox »

Keithkilvo1 wrote:Thinking of buying one of these and wondered what the views/experiences of the forum members are of these machines.
I’m not interested in manufacturing one but people’s views on the ones already available ie Thumbler, Lyman cyclone, Frankford Arsenals one
I've been wet tumbling for about five years. The results are excellent, and I find the process only marginally more hassle than vibratory tumbling. My tumbler only handles a hundred cases though, so working through a thousand takes longer overall.

I have a Thumler, and I do not recommend it. It is designed for a dry process and is not suitable for wet work. The inside of the drum is unfinished, and after the very first time I used mine rust was evident through the seams to the surface of the the exterior paint. I didn't get a satisfactory outcome from the supplier or the manufacturer. If you do get a Thumler, be sure to prep and spray the inside with a suitable paint before you get water anywhere near it.

If I was buying again I would defininately go for a FART. The FART has a much higher capacity and a plastic drum, so no rust problems. I have a large poly hexagonal drum waiting for the day my Thumler disintegrates into flakes, which I'll pair with a treadmill-derived base to solve my capacity and rust problems.
Gh0st
Posts: 785
Joined: Fri Aug 11, 2017 10:30 am
Home club or Range: FDPC
Location: West Country
Contact:

Re: Wet rotary tumbler

#4 Post by Gh0st »

I’ve just switched to wet tumbling. the results are far more pleasing if you like shiny brass.

Also much better at cleaning primer pockets on my .44 and .357 cases.

Just brought a Lyman. Check my link below there’s a little video in there somewhere.
All views expressed are my own unless otherwise stated! So please take your time to consider my opinions as biased to what i think is best....

http://www.bulletsandpixels.co.uk www.fdpc.org.uk
The Gun Pimp
Posts: 1154
Joined: Fri Dec 10, 2010 3:08 pm
Contact:

Re: Wet rotary tumbler

#5 Post by The Gun Pimp »

Keithkilvo1 wrote:Thinking of buying one of these and wondered what the views/experiences of the forum members are of these machines.
I’m not interested in manufacturing one but people’s views on the ones already available ie Thumbler, Lyman cyclone, Frankford Arsenals one
Cheers
If you want to read an un-biased report http://www.targetshooter.co.uk/?s=Tumbler
User avatar
dromia
Site Admin
Posts: 19964
Joined: Sat Nov 06, 2010 4:57 am
Home club or Range: The Highlands of Scotland. Cycling Proficiency 1964. Felton & District rifle club. Teesdale Pistol and Rifle club.
Location: Sutherland and Co Durham
Contact:

Re: Wet rotary tumbler

#6 Post by dromia »

rox wrote:
Keithkilvo1 wrote:Thinking of buying one of these and wondered what the views/experiences of the forum members are of these machines.
I’m not interested in manufacturing one but people’s views on the ones already available ie Thumbler, Lyman cyclone, Frankford Arsenals one
I've been wet tumbling for about five years. The results are excellent, and I find the process only marginally more hassle than vibratory tumbling. My tumbler only handles a hundred cases though, so working through a thousand takes longer overall.

I have a Thumler, and I do not recommend it. It is designed for a dry process and is not suitable for wet work. The inside of the drum is unfinished, and after the very first time I used mine rust was evident through the seams to the surface of the the exterior paint. I didn't get a satisfactory outcome from the supplier or the manufacturer. If you do get a Thumler, be sure to prep and spray the inside with a suitable paint before you get water anywhere near it.

If I was buying again I would definitely go for a FART. The FART has a much higher capacity and a plastic drum, so no rust problems. I have a large poly hexagonal drum waiting for the day my Thumler disintegrates into flakes, which I'll pair with a treadmill-derived base to solve my capacity and rust problems.
I have been using a Thumler wet tumbler (with ceramic for my black powder cases, steel pins are a faff on too far for me, still prefer dry tumbling my smokeless cases) for over 20 years with no issues, the water shouldn't get anywhere near the inside of the metal drum as the rubber internal liner makes a physical seal with the metal drum so the water cannot get between them.

If it is designed for dry tumbling only then you have bought the wrong model for the application.
Image

Come on Bambi get some

Imperial Good Metric Bad
Analogue Good Digital Bad

Fecking stones

Real farmers don't need subsidies

Cow's farts matter!

For fine firearms and requisites visit

http://www.pukkabundhooks.com/
User avatar
Ovenpaa
Site Supporter Since 2015
Posts: 24680
Joined: Fri Nov 05, 2010 8:27 pm
Location: Årbjerg, Morsø DK
Contact:

Re: Wet rotary tumbler

#7 Post by Ovenpaa »

I used a Thumbler type for a while and it was fine however unbolting the top to see if your brass was clean was a PITA so I moved to a LEM. The basic LEM is undoubtedly more expensive however you can see what is happening and grab a handful of brass to inspect whilst it is running. It is also easier to empty and flush the cases with clean water if needed.
/d

Du lytter aldrig til de ord jeg siger. Du ser mig kun for det tøj jeg har paa ...

Shed Journal
User avatar
bradaz11
Sporadic Site Supporter
Posts: 4714
Joined: Mon Jun 02, 2014 1:23 am
Home club or Range: The tunnel at Charmouth, BWSS
Location: Bristol
Contact:

Re: Wet rotary tumbler

#8 Post by bradaz11 »

I use one of the chinese type ones. no regrets. I just wouldn't leave it plugged in when not using it. then got a dehydrater to dry the brass out
When guns are outlawed, only Outlaws will have guns
rox
Posts: 1895
Joined: Fri Dec 10, 2010 1:33 pm
Contact:

Re: Wet rotary tumbler

#9 Post by rox »

dromia wrote:If it is designed for dry tumbling only then you have bought the wrong model for the application.
I wish I'd known that at the time. Which model should have been included in a wet tumbling brass cleaning kit?

I have the Thumler Model B. It is designed for rock tumbling, which is a dry process. It was sold as a wet process brass cleaner by shooting suppliers, bundled with STM media. The manufacturers weren't willing to honour the warranty when the tumbler had been used for a wet process.
dromia wrote:the water shouldn't get anywhere near the inside of the metal drum as the rubber internal liner makes a physical seal with the metal drum so the water cannot get between them
The liner does not make a perfect water-tight seal. In the words of the manufacturer, it is a "removable rubber liner for quieter use".
As others have found, the unfinished interior of the drum needs painting to prevent rust. Unless you know that and do it before the first use it is too late.


This is the rust I saw after the very first use:

Image

Image


...and after 6 months; flakes of rust on the base, and the seam is opening over half of its length:

Image

Image
Maggot
Posts: 739
Joined: Tue Sep 22, 2015 2:22 pm
Home club or Range: HRA and LERA

Re: Wet rotary tumbler

#10 Post by Maggot »

Ovenpaa wrote:I used a Thumbler type for a while and it was fine however unbolting the top to see if your brass was clean was a PITA so I moved to a LEM. The basic LEM is undoubtedly more expensive however you can see what is happening and grab a handful of brass to inspect whilst it is running. It is also easier to empty and flush the cases with clean water if needed.
And it is still running very nicely thanks Dave. Some may see it as a faff but to be honest its a brilliant way to clean cases well. What I did find was that the sea clean was not quite doing the job, but a squirt of hairy lipped squid sorted that nicely.

Rox, I think someone was pulling a fast one chap because I would expect the rubber liner to be in it for wet or dry. It still makes a bit of a racket with the liner fitted, I just place it on some old foam rubber and a towel and happy days.

To empty I just dump the lot into a plastic bowl and fish the cases out, rinse, strain and flick any water out. Roll them 10 at a time on a towel and air dry.
Post Reply

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Bing [Bot] and 8 guests